McMahon & Associates
HOME | MISSION | SERVICES | SELECTING AN ATTORNEY | FEES | PROFILES | CONTACT

Selecting An Attorney


How to Select an Attorney to Represent You
When You are Charged with a Crime

I. Make sure that the attorney you choose is a criminal defense attorney.
II. Make sure the attorney is a trial-experienced attorney.
III. Make sure the attorney is experienced in handling your type of case.
IV. Make sure the attorney you hired will actually represent you.
V. Hire the best attorney you can afford.
VI. Effort is all anyone can guarantee.
VII. Questions to ask the attorney.
VIII. Warning signs.

  1. MAKE SURE THAT THE ATTORNEY YOU CHOOSE IS A CRIMINAL DEFENSE ATTORNEY.

    1. Criminal law is different than civil law. Criminal law encompasses all the areas of law that are concerned with either prosecuting someone for or defending someone who has been charged with committing a criminal offense. These areas include representing someone who is charged with committing a crime in the district court, appealing a criminal case to a higher court, representing someone charged with violating probation or parole, and expunging (or sealing) someone’s criminal record. All other areas of law are civil law. Criminal law uses different procedures in the court room as well as in filing legal documents. Criminal law also has more evidentiary rules than civil law.

    2. Criminal charges are serious, requiring serious representation. There is always the possibility that someone could be put in jail when they commit a crime and a conviction is publicly recorded and remains in the public record forever unless it can be expunged (or sealed). In some circumstances where a person is not a United States citizen, even a misdemeanor conviction could cause him to be deported. Law is a complex field and most of the attorneys today specialize in an area of law. The prosecutors are specialized in criminal law, shouldn’t your attorney be specialized in criminal law as well.
      Back To Top

  2. MAKE SURE THAT THE ATTORNEY IS A TRIAL-EXPERIENCED ATTORNEY.

    1. A criminal defense attorney should be a trial-experienced attorney. A little less than ten percent of all criminal cases go to trial. It stands to reason that if the attorney has handled a good number of criminal cases, he has also had criminal trials. You don’t want your case to be your attorney’s first criminal trial. A criminal defense attorney should always be prepared to go to trial on any criminal case he handles because your attorney’s job is to do everything legally possible to defend you on your case.

      An experienced criminal defense attorney will evaluate your case by reviewing the evidence and asking himself what are the strengths and weaknesses of this case and what evidence could be used at trial. The experienced criminal defense attorney will only consider plea bargaining after he has thoroughly evaluated your case. An experienced criminal defense attorney knows that he will never know for sure whether your case will go to trial or not. There are some situations where you have nothing to lose by going to trial because either there is no offer or the consequences are so great. Therefore, it is very important that the agreement you sign with an attorney always includes trial. You never want to be put in a position where you are out of options because your agreement says your lawyer won’t represent you at trial. It is the person charged with a crime who has the right to decide whether or not he wants to go to trial, not the attorney.
      Back To Top

      If your case goes to trial, you will want an attorney who has tried criminal cases before--the prosecutor has. Don’t be afraid to ask your attorney about his criminal trial experience. You have the right to know whether the attorney you are hiring is qualified to handle your case or not.

      Everybody wants to remember their wins and forget their losses but a good criminal defense attorney will have lost cases. Why is that? It indicates that the attorney goes that one final step when there is no possibility of a better deal. Many of the people a criminal defense attorney represents are guilty of some crime. A good criminal defense attorney makes the State prove their case. In doing so, he is protecting your rights.

    2. A criminal defense attorney should be a motion-experienced attorney. A motion is a request made by an attorney when he wants the judge to rule on some legal question. Before an attorney even discusses plea bargaining, he should have evaluated your case in terms of the motions that might be made. You have a right to bring any necessary motions to protect your rights. When you enter a plea, you waive those rights. Make sure you have an attorney who recognizes any issues that should be made in a motion before you enter a plea and waive those rights.
      Back To Top

  3. MAKE SURE THE ATTORNEY IS EXPERIENCED IN HANDLING YOUR TYPE OF CASE.

    1. Some criminal defense attorneys focus their practice in certain types of crimes. For example, our firm primarily handles felony charges. If we can handle a felony, we certainly can handle a misdemeanor or a gross misdemeanor. The reverse, however, is not necessarily true. Most lawyers who handle predominately DUI and traffic offenses should not accept a felony case.

      The majority of the felonies we handle are either drug crimes or criminal sexual conduct crimes. For example, the percentage of types of cases we handled last year break down as follows:

      Criminal Appeals 24%
      Drug cases (all felony level offenses) 19%
      Criminal sexual conduct (all felonies) 19%
      Post-convictions 9%
      Probation Violations 6%
      Murder 6%*
      Felonies in which a gun is used (not murder) 5%
      Juvenile (all felonies) 4%
      Felony assaults 3%
      Assorted felonies (car theft, burglary) 3%
      Expungements 2%
      * Most murder cases are handled by the public defender.


      44% of all of our cases is representation in the trial court of people charged with drug cases, criminal sexual conduct cases, or murder.

      33% of all of our cases is representation on post-trial matters (criminal appeals or post-conviction proceedings).

      Back To Top

      The majority of the crimes committed in this country are misdemeanor DUIs and misdemeanor assaults (most surveys indicate that these two crimes represent almost 90% of the crimes committed) . This breakdown therefore indicates that a disproportionate majority of the cases that we handle are felony cases and the majority of those felonies are either drug or criminal sexual conduct cases. You should not hesitate to ask the attorney what his or her main focus of practice is.

      You will very quickly have an idea of what area of law your attorney primarily practices by the type of questions he or she asks you. For example, an attorney who handles many drug cases will ask you whether a search warrant was involved, where you were searched, did you consent, was a canine involved, were you frisked, the number of officers involved, were their guns drawn, etc. Your attorney is simply searching for suppression issues which means that he or she is assessing the complexity of your case.
      Back To Top

      You will also know very quickly if your attorney is used to handling criminal cases and especially felony level offenses if the attorney asks you questions about your criminal history points, prior record, whether you are on probation or parole, if you are the only person charged on the crime, whether you are considered a career offender, etc. Pay attention to what the attorney is asking you. He is once again assessing the complexity of your case and trying to determine the amount of work it will require. Remember that good attorneys are in demand and cannot take every case that comes their way. The attorney needs to assess the amount of time your case will take and sometimes whether or not it is of interest to him or her.

  4. MAKE SURE THE ATTORNEY YOU HIRED WILL ACTUALLY REPRESENT YOU.

    1. Make sure that the attorney you interviewed will handle your case; and if they aren’t, find out who is. Make sure that you haven’t gone through this entire interview process only to have a different lawyer represent you. Make sure that the lawyer who you have chosen is the person who will actually be there for you. You haven’t spent all this time and energy determining who you are going to entrust with your future only to have a less-experienced attorney appear in court with you.
      Back To Top

  5. HIRE THE BEST ATTORNEY YOU CAN AFFORD.

    1. Low priced representation is not always a bargain. Every attorney has an obligation not to take on more cases than he can handle. When an attorney accepts representation on your case, he needs to fully evaluate your case, prepare any motions that are needed, and be prepared to return to court as many times as necessary to get the best result for you. Finally, there is always the possibility that a case may end up in trial. A good attorney is in demand and cannot take every case and neither can he afford to take a case for a low fee where he will lose a lot of money. A good attorney will not compromise his representation by accepting a fee on a case that is so low that he cannot give it the attention it deserves. As is true of most things in life, you get what you pay for. In criminal law, the consequences of the lowest fee hit hard and stay with you for life.
      Back To Top

    2. There is nothing shameful in being represented by a public defender. There are very good public defenders just as there are very good private attorneys. Just because you pay someone money does not make them better. If you cannot afford a quality private criminal defense attorney, you should not hesitate to use the public defender if you qualify. Public defenders are lawyers who are experienced and specialize in criminal law. That is what you need.

      It is serious when you are charged with a crime and you should take an active role in determining who is going to represent you on the charges. Don’t be afraid to ask yourself why a lawyer feels a need to solicit business by mail or will bargain with his fee. Remember, that the best attorneys, just like other professionals, usually obtain the majority of their business through referrals from other attorneys or their former clients. Don’t be afraid to ask questions, your representation is the most important decision you will make.
      Back To Top

  6. EFFORT IS ALL ANYONE CAN GUARANTEE.

    1. An attorney can never guarantee that he will win your case. Your attorney can only promise that he can do his best. The attorney cannot control many things that will ultimately determine the outcome of your case, because your attorney cannot control the other people involved in your case. The attorney can only control the amount of effort, knowledge and experience he or she puts into your case; and whether or not he or she is methodically protecting each and every one of your constitutional rights.
      Back To Top

  7. QUESTIONS TO ASK THE ATTORNEY.

    1. What types of law do you practice?
    2. Tell me about your trial experience.
    3. Tell me about your motion practice experience.
    4. What percentage of the cases you handle are the type of case I have?
    5. What percentage of your cases require suppression hearings?
    6. What steps will you go through in defending me on these charges?
    7. Will you or someone else actually handle my case?
    8. How much will it cost to represent me and how did you arrive at that decision?
      Back To Top

  8. WARNING SIGNS.

    1. An attorney who is soliciting your business--ask yourself why they need to do this.
    2. An attorney who bargains on the price.
    3. An attorney who practices in many areas of law.
    4. An attorney who promises they can win your case.
    5. An attorney who immediately says they can’t use some evidence against you--ask him why. The answer is never as simple as it seems.
    6. An attorney who says he has never lost a trial.
    7. An attorney who says he just won a trial in a case like yours. Ask who the judge was and then verify it.
      Back To Top

EMAIL | OFFICE LOCATION | DISCLAIMER